A federal judge is considering whether investigators illegally rummaged through personal digital devices in a criminal case involving Maryland State Senator Dalya Attar. During a Friday hearing, defense lawyers for Attar's brother and a co-defendant argued that the search warrants used to access their phones and Google accounts were overbroad and violated the Fourth Amendment.
What are the allegations?
The legal battle stems from accusations that Joseph Attar and Baltimore police officer Kalman Finkelstein conspired to blackmail a former political aide. Prosecutors allege the group recorded the aide having an affair and threatened to release the footage to prevent her from criticizing Senator Attar's 2018 campaign for the Maryland House of Delegates. While extortion charges were dismissed earlier this summer, the defendants still face conspiracy and wiretapping charges.
Is there a difference between phones and computers?
A central debate during the hearing focused on the scope of digital privacy. The defense argued that a mobile device contains far more intimate data than a standard computer.
- Defense counsel Gregg Bernstein argued that warrants lacked the necessary "particularity" required by law.
- Attorneys claimed investigators spent years searching through private accounts without finding the alleged blackmail video.
- Prosecutors countered that the searches were not "carte blanche" and were limited in scope to the investigation.
The judge questioned whether a phone should be treated differently than a laptop, a point the prosecution argued was unnecessary as a phone functions as a small computer.
Context of the digital search
The defense maintains that the warrants essentially allowed investigators to look at the entirety of the defendants' lives. Specifically, Finkelstein’s lawyer argued that the search of his client's Google account and phone covered almost every aspect of his existence. This challenge to cellphone evidence is critical because the data obtained from these devices could form the backbone of the government's conspiracy and wiretapping case.
What happens next?
No ruling was issued during the hearing. The judge noted that a technical outage involving Outlook prevented her from reviewing recent filings and necessary materials. The court's decision will determine if the digital data gathered by federal agents can be used as evidence in the upcoming trial. All three defendants, including Senator Attar, have pleaded not guilty.
FAQ
What charges are currently being faced?
The defendants are facing federal charges of conspiracy and wiretapping.
Why was the evidence challenged?
Defense lawyers claim the search warrants were unconstitutional because they allowed investigators to search through nearly every aspect of the defendants' private lives.
