Prince Edward Island has ordered an independent inquiry into how the Byron Carr murder investigation was handled, after missing evidence forced prosecutors to drop charges. Retired Nova Scotia justice Duncan Beveridge will lead the review, examining the Charlottetown Police Service's conduct in a case that began with a killing in 1988.

Why did the prosecution fall apart?

Carr, a 36-year-old teacher, was found dead in his Charlottetown home on November 12, 1988. The case went unsolved for decades until police arrested Todd Joseph Gallant in 2024 and charged him with first-degree murder and interfering with human remains. Last month, the Crown Attorneys' Office withdrew all charges after learning that key items, including the kitchen knife and the towel used to strangle Carr, could no longer be found.

What will the Byron Carr murder investigation review examine?

Justice Beveridge has been appointed under the province's Police Act. His mandate covers the police service's file management and oversight, its storage and control of evidence, coordination with other agencies, and its dealings with Crown prosecutors. The review is also meant to assess whether the force's practices for major crime files meet current standards expected in the province.

Justice and Public Safety Minister Bloyce Thompson said the review will not decide liability. Its purpose, he said, is to confirm that police and prosecutors are meeting accepted standards for major crime investigations. He added that Beveridge can file an interim report if he decides he needs additional powers.

Who is leading the inquiry?

Beveridge spent years on the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal and worked on both sides of the courtroom earlier in his career, as a Crown prosecutor and a defence lawyer. He is a past president of the Nova Scotia Criminal Lawyers' Association and took part in the review of the Westray prosecution in Nova Scotia.

FAQ

When does the review start?

Work is scheduled to begin on January 4, 2027, and is expected to take several months to a year.

Will the findings be released?

Thompson said the final report and its recommendations will be delivered to him and then made public.